Stillwater Reservoir

Herkimer - New York


  • 24 catches

  • 39 followers

  • 1 spots

Site includes accessible features

Find Local Fishing Spots on the Interactive Map!

Already have an account? Sign in

or
*Used to locate nearby fishing activity


By signing up with Fishidy you accept the User Terms and Privacy Policy.

Stillwater Reservoir Fishing Reports

Recently shared catches and fishing spots

  1. David Lyndaker
    - Stillwater Reservoir

    Smallmouth Bass with a minnow

  2. Doctor Fish
    - Stillwater Reservoir

    Details: Chicken Shoals

    Under & above shoals

    1. Doctor Fish 0
      Posted a comment ... didn't do anything ! So repeat ..... 2 guys in September, 2 1/2 days, Sunny, 8 -- 12 mph winds, 72 degrees water temp, 74 -- 76 air, trolling ...more and live bait, 20' -- 35' of water, 120 -- 130 Small Mouth in the 13" range and 4 ( 16" ) , Great Fishing at this time of the year.
  3. RobCaserta
    - Stillwater Reservoir

    Details: Largemouth Bass

    6-8 FOW worked the splits in the weeds where my bait could drop nice and slow to the bottom, didn't even get half way down and this one sucked my bait right ...more up. Hit every hole and it'll pay off!

  4. Ryan Rossi
    - Stillwater Reservoir

    Details: Largemouth Bass with a Booyah pad crasher

    Caught this guy near a spill way around 7pm. This guy just cracked 5lbs. Smashed the frog in open water.

    1. 4o1PIGS 0
      It really is a shame that you need a set of T!TS to make it onto the popular page...
    2. diggerman 0
      Dandy!!!!
    3. Gone_fishingg 0
      Chunk!
    4. Mason Cizek 0
      Hog.
    5. View full conversation
  5. kayleigh3
    - Stillwater Reservoir

    Details: Largemouth Bass with a Watermelon senko

    My first largemouth bass! caught using a watermelon senko 👍🎣

    1. Wayne Harris 0
      With that said shut up n just fish and mass and ri got some big bass just gotta find em
    2. Wayne Harris 0
      U people are the worst and @polaris 500 I would fly to Texas and rip ur head off if u where saying stuff like that to my chic ..... Just saying
    3. solorider4o8 0
      I know
    4. Jeff Goldberg 0
      This whole little soap opera was entertaining.
    5. BgSlayer 0
      @4o1PIGS I wish I was that bass hehehe
    6. 4o1PIGS 0
      I cant belive this has 50 comments lol
    7. matthew johnson 0
      Fag*#t
    8. matthew johnson 0
      I don't care about the Conversation but please stop using the word faggot thank u @4o1PIGS
    9. gilligan 0
      What's there not to like about a pretty girl holding a fish!
    10. MrPopular 0
      Congrats! You made it on the popular page on Jul 29, 2014!
    11. Gabe Mitchell 0
      Wow. Welcome Kayleigh. Sorry for all the drama.
    12. Gone_fishingg 0
      K @kayleigh3
    13. kayleigh3 0
      @gone_fishingg the arguing actually stopped yesterday and you just started it back up again. Stop commenting
    14. 4o1PIGS 0
      Thats legit the only point im tryna make and ppl are on here tryna give me relationship advice hhahah
    15. 4o1PIGS 0
      Yeah exactly a fishing app not lets attack the 100 girls that are actually on this app so they all get creeped out lol
    16. Gone_fishingg 0
      I'm tagging him so he can stop all this arguing... This is a fishing app not a gossip chat @4o1PIGS
    17. 4o1PIGS 0
      Sorry @lcastaneda22 i meant to tag @Gone__fishingg
    18. 4o1PIGS 0
      @RobCaserta @rednessisill @G_Demers and @nmolak will all back that up so all you weirdos need to chill lol
    19. 4o1PIGS 0
      Hahah what are you tagging @MulletHead cause you think hes gunna kick me off the app or something? @lcastaneda22...pretty sure ive been on this app longer than most ...more these ppl lol
    20. Gone_fishingg 0
      Jeez chill out @4o1PIGS @MulletHead
    21. lcastaneda22 0
      @4o1PIGS, I agree there are people out there with some killer catches that don't get the credit they deserve, while there are pics of some ladies w/o a fish ...more on the pop. page. Not hating, just saying.
    22. 4o1PIGS 0
      ^^And thats why you're stupid...the average size of largemouth bass in RI is not big at all. You probably dont even know where RI is but hey you're just ...more an uneducated hillbilly so i forgive you sir
    23. polaris500 0
      Now u can say end of story
    24. polaris500 0
      I think the point I proved was better on how your acting like a little B**ch! I guess you and the fish u catch have something in common seeing how all the fish you ...more catch are little b**ch fish!
    25. 4o1PIGS 0
      End of story lol
    26. 4o1PIGS 0
      I made her do this to prove a point that a girl can get a fishing scout and be on the popular page overnight for a 6oz fucking bass and I've seen guys get less ...more cred holding a 10lb hammer
    27. 4o1PIGS 0
      You're all tryna get laid on fishing scout and act like your not when you get called out for it hahah...go catch your alligator gar buddy i hope one bites your ...more hand off
    28. 4o1PIGS 0
      You're such a bitch @polaris500
    29. polaris500 0
      @4o1PIGS I have no interest in your ol lady I'm just proving a point on how much you sound like a insecure little b**ch!
    30. atxflyfishing 0
      @4o1PIGS girls are rare on this app so everyone jumps onto the opportunity
    31. 4o1PIGS 0
      @polaris500 i think you got the wrong app my friend...try tinder? Plentyoffish? Cristianmingle? Lol
    32. 4o1PIGS 0
      The thirst is real on fishing scout 💦💦
    33. kayleigh3 0
      @polaris500 no thanks I'm all set.
    34. MrPopular 0
      Congrats! You made it on the popular page on Jul 28, 2014!
    35. atxflyfishing 0
      😂 I'm dying @polaris500
    36. polaris500 0
      Wow your hot you can come fishing with me anytime. Leave the boyfriend at home where he belongs
    37. thedevman1 0
      I'd take it as a compliment that you have good taste. And how can they be "Fa**ots" if they think your girl is nice looking? Lighten up, it's not ...more like they're people you know personally :)
    38. 4o1PIGS 0
      Lol
    39. crookcody19 0
      Dude no one has said anything about how she looks or anything @4o1PIGS
    40. Esgar Montalvo 0
      I'm removing my credit...
    41. Josh Parker 0
      I'm no dr. Phil that's just my opinion... Tight lines 2 u guys & I hope your relationship withstands the "test of time"
    42. Josh Parker 0
      Honestly bro even if someone was, jealousy is NEVER a good look... If u trust ur girl and have confidence in her love, NOTHING ELSE MATTERS! If I were u, I'd ...more take it as a compliment!! @4o1PIGS
    43. Josh Parker 0
      Who's "hitting on her" lol @4o1PIGS
    44. 4o1PIGS 0
      Its a 6oz. Bass everyone can calm down hahaha
    45. 4o1PIGS 0
      Im fine just appreciate it if everyone wasn't hitting on my girl lol @fishON423
    46. Josh Parker 0
      Nice fish... Welcome 2 the family!!
    47. Josh Parker 0
      @4o1PIGS You alright brother??
    48. 4o1PIGS 0
      Prime example of the blert i posted last year about all the fucking fagget creeps on this app hahahah @RobCaserta @G_Demers
    49. 4o1PIGS 0
      My babe 😜 gotta love all these creeps @kayleigh3
    50. crookcody19 0
      Popular page here we come!👍 ahaha but good catch.
    51. Chuck LaBruna 0
      Congratulations! That's the first of many more to come!
    52. Brandon alt 0
      Welcome to the skout
    53. Reel_Smooth 0
      Welcome to FishingScout
    54. Reel_Smooth 0
      Congrats! Just wait till you hook a 5 pounder or up.
    55. Cat_Assassin 0
      Congrats!!!
    56. kayleigh3 0
      Thanks! @Fisherman_Rob
    57. kayleigh3 0
      @fish
    58. kayleigh3 0
      Thanks 👌
    59. Fisherman_Rob 0
      Nice fish
    60. View full conversation
  6. Ryan Rossi
    - Stillwater Reservoir

    Details: Northern Pike with a dead shiners

    Ice fishing for the first time this year... Windy around 20 degrees. No luck but feels good to b fishin again

    1. Tripp Cave 0
      Awesome
  7. Ryan Rossi
    - Stillwater Reservoir

    Details: Smallmouth Bass with a rattle trap

    Fishing from shore knee deep in the water. There was a steep drop off a step in front of me... This smallie literally tagged the lure a foot in front of me .Caught ...more around 7pm, calm, temp low 70's

  8. kurt walker
    - Stillwater Reservoir

    Details: Largemouth Bass with a creature bait

    Pitchin to the kitchen waiting for a hungry biggen

  9. 4o1PIGS
    - Stillwater Reservoir

    Details: Chain Pickerel

    Fake frog

  10. Ryan Rossi
    - Stillwater Reservoir

    My buddy got hung up on a branch close to shore and the frog inhaled the fake frog we ended up catching six giant bull frogs while fishing lilly pads with fake frogs

    1. G_Demers 0
      When we linkin up Rossi @rednessisill
    2. Chris Skinner 0
      @matt haha that's unacceptable bro! Gotta fix that!
    3. Matt Dobson 0
      Ha. Obviously I don't fish often enough @cowboy713
    4. Chris Skinner 0
      @matt oh yea man, do this all the time, cast it out let it sit twitch periodically and the bullfrogs just can't help it
    5. Matt Dobson 0
      That's crazy. Had no idea they ate their own.
    6. Jbird_401 0
      This happens all the time to my buddy when he fishes a frog in this one pond around the real mucky algae area. It's like the bullfrogs just attack the frog lures ...more lol
    7. View full conversation

Find more fishing reports in New York

  • Fourth Lake

    A wilderness fishing experience? No. A good place to fish thanks to the really nice trout, good landlocked salmon, nice muskies, good pike, lots of 2lbs smallmouth bass, and decent panfish? Yes. In th...

    Followers
    133
    Catches
    12
    Spots
    7
  • Big Moose Lake

    You'll find a little bit of everything in Big Moose Lake. For you coldwater anglers there are brown trout that run 2-3lbs, brook trout that average 2-3lb, nice stocked splake, and a few lake trout. If...

    Followers
    41
    Catches
    1
    Spots
    0
  • Third Lake

    Third Lake is a 180 acre lake located in Herkimer County.

    Followers
    27
    Catches
    0
    Spots
    3
  • Soft Maple Reservoir

    Site includes accessible features

    Followers
    26
    Catches
    1
    Spots
    0
Loading...