Killbuck Creek

Holmes - Ohio


  • 12 catches

  • 117 followers

  • spots

A section of the Killbuck Creek in Holmes County, Ohio.

Find Local Fishing Spots on the Interactive Map!

Already have an account? Sign in

or
*Used to locate nearby fishing activity


By signing up with Fishidy you accept the User Terms and Privacy Policy.

Killbuck Creek Fishing Reports

Recently shared catches and fishing spots

  1. Nicole Gidley
    - Killbuck Creek

    Saugeye with a Creek chub

    1. Robert Anderson 0
      that's a bowfin not a saugeye
    2. Tara Chapman 0
      looks like a bowfin
    3. View full conversation
  2. Tanner Theis
    - Killbuck Creek

    Details: 10 in. Sauger

  3. Mark Blough
    - Killbuck Creek

    Yellow Perch with a Nightcrawler

  4. Matthew Ormesher
    - Killbuck Creek

    caught 2 channels the smaller one was 20"

    26 in. Channel Catfish with a Creek Chub

  5. Matthew Ormesher
    - Killbuck Creek

    wait on cats to bite running lures and this guy decides to join the party :)

    14 in. Smallmouth Bass with a cicada lure (some Chinese thing)

    1. Matthew Ormesher 0
      True that is awesome ... I am about to post a pic about what we were tearing into tonight ... :) I can't wait to start exploring the buck more it's my favorite ...more local body ... everything else is like 40 mins and up out sucks. ... we should get together some time and go out on the buck :) I have actually read last night about the apple creek ... that is awesome too
    2. Andrew Kane 0
      Well the trout probably come from the little Apple creek that runs around Wooster. Local trout inc. club stocks them in a small section of the creek. They wash down ...more all the time. Caught several rainbows at the bridge on silver road. The Saugeye were about 10 Years ago. I was surprised when I caught them. But I asked a ODNR rep at the Wayne county fair if he has ever heard of them in there and he said you should never be surprised what you find in there. There are several private lakes that are located on the north end of the killbuck that are stocked with an array of different species and often they get washed out into the buck. On top of that he told me that on occasion if there are surplus in stocked fish for several local lakes they have dumped them In the buck before. So even though it is rare they have been caught in the there. Now the state stopped stacking Saugeye in north east Ohio several years back for fear of them ending in Lake Erie which they don't want. The largest of the Saugeye I caught was 6lbs too big to be a sauger.
    3. Matthew Ormesher 0
      Sorry Google it just now I have been lied to they can reproduce there is a 2-3% chance of them being created in the wild and yes they do reproduce as saugeye ... ...more so I apologize for misinfo but I still think it's sauger ... they would have had to swim from the river up the stream or there would have to be walleye and sauger in there and I never heard of walleye in the Killbuck lol
    4. Matthew Ormesher 0
      Would be sauger in killbuck saugeye are sterile I think and can't reproduce ... I never heard of trout in the Killbuck but in feeder streams that's crazy ...more I was always told the water isn't good enough in the Killbuck for trout ... hmm ... but thanks man ... I am gonna have to plan something out one weekend ...
    5. Andrew Kane 0
      I live in the Wooster area I have not fished north of smithville western rd. But I have fished all the way south of shreve swaps.and pretty much found all of those ...more along the way along with large mouth and bowfins and crappie and other panfish I have even found trout. And saugeyes!
    6. Matthew Ormesher 0
      do you know how far up the smallies cats or pike run?
    7. Andrew Kane 0
      Yeah I use my kayak a lot. There are def some good holes with nice smallies in them. Not too interested in wadding in the mud either
    8. Matthew Ormesher 0
      Yeah I will be honest it totally caught me off guard ... I didn't expect that ... I have been thinking about getting another paddle for my inflatable and my ...more buddy and I hitting it and just tie of and fish hard to get too spots ... just worried about dragging I really don't like the thought of walking in that mud mess ... ugh lol
    9. Andrew Kane 0
      There are some nice smallies in there. Very under fishes though
    10. View full conversation
  6. Matthew Ormesher
    - Killbuck Creek

    Nothing to write home about ... just a little guy I got while wait for cats to bite ... he was a bit big for this but I am trying him as cat bait as I post this ...more :)

    Bluegill with a cicada lure (some Chinese thing)

  7. Matthew Ormesher
    - Killbuck Creek

    Caught in about 5 mins after tossing out... caught in low water levels on the creek

    25 in. Channel Catfish with a chicken liver

    1. Matthew Ormesher 0
      I agree man love ... low water fishing the buck is the best too
    2. Andrew Kane 0
      Gotta love fishing on the buck
    3. View full conversation
  8. Andrew Kane
    - Killbuck Creek

    Secret spot on the buck! Right at dark after work was nice

    4 lb. 10 oz. 22 in. Largemouth Bass with a spinner bait

    1. Tim Steinmetz 0
      Awesome bass!
  9. Jason Howe
    - Killbuck Creek

    Northern Pike with a Kvd Spinner

  10. Jason Howe
    - Killbuck Creek

    14 in. Saugeye

Find more fishing reports in Ohio

  • Salt Fork Lake

    Salt Fork Lake provides angling opportunities for those who seek largemouth bass, walleye, channel catfish, muskellunge, crappie, and various species of sunfish.  Flathead catfish, smallmouth bass, an...

    Followers
    862
    Catches
    69
    Spots
    11
  • Portage Lake State Parks Chain of Lakes

    The Portage Lake State Parks Chain of Lakes consists of six small lakes called Rex Lake, Mud Lake, Turkeyfoot, the East, West and North Reservoirs, and Lake Nimisila. Some of the lakes, which total o...

    Followers
    599
    Catches
    21
    Spots
    5
  • Atwood Lake

    Atwood Lake is stocked with saugeye annually and is considered one of the finest saugeye fisheries in Northeast Ohio. It also has excellent populations of largemouth bass, bluegill, crappies, and chan...

    Followers
    584
    Catches
    32
    Spots
    8
  • Nimisila Reservoir

    Nimisila Reservoir is a large dam located on the southernmost shore of the Portage Lakes Chain of Lakes.

    Followers
    546
    Catches
    119
    Spots
    3
Loading...