Eaton Brook Reservoir

Madison - New York


  • 10 catches

  • 137 followers

  • 4 spots

The main gamefish found in the reservoir are largemouth and smallmouth bass, walleye, rainbow trout and chain pickerel. Panfish such as bluegills, pumpkinseed sunfish, yellow perch, black crappie and rock bass can also be found in Eaton Brook.

Find Local Fishing Spots on the Interactive Map!

Already have an account? Sign in

or
*Used to locate nearby fishing activity


By signing up with Fishidy you accept the User Terms and Privacy Policy.

Eaton Brook Reservoir Fishing Reports

Recently shared catches and fishing spots

  1. Christopher Reese
    - Eaton Brook Reservoir

    Yellow Perch with a red worms

  2. John Finch
    - Eaton Brook Reservoir

    Details: 4 lb. 7 oz. Largemouth Bass 4lbs 7 oz with a Swim bait

  3. Rob Bunzey
    - Eaton Brook Reservoir

    Details: Smallies with a Senko worms (Magic Shad)

    Excellent spot in 12-15' of water off of this point, Smallies will cruise all day foraging, if the bite is slow, switch to shad raps or rapala dt6's

  4. Rob Bunzey
    - Eaton Brook Reservoir

    Details: Walleye with a worm harness Chrome bladed

    Slow Slow Slow troll in 20' of water, avoid rockies and bluegill by keeping the worm just above the grass. Monster Eyes have been caught here for as long as ...more I can remember. 3 days prior and during Full-moon conditions in the summer can be crazy good.

  5. Rob Bunzey
    - Eaton Brook Reservoir

    Details: Smallie Point

    Quick drop off, two docks close by. Hard pan bottom, with shale outcropping in 20' of water. DT8 and DT12's are kiiller here

    1. Rob Bunzey 0
      Look at the map of Eaton Brook, the green and yellow markers will show the locations
    2. mike bell 0
      wheres that at?
    3. View full conversation
  6. liz and ryan mcgee
    - Eaton Brook Reservoir

    Details: 10 in. Largemouth Bass with a Hook and Worm

    Caught right off the causeway

  7. Peter Blake
    - Eaton Brook Reservoir

    Caught a 27in walkeye

    10 lb. 1 oz. 325 in. Walleye with a jig

  8. Rob Bunzey
    - Eaton Brook Reservoir

    Details: 60 in. Bullhead with a Nightcrawlers

    Pre and post full moon conditions, add a 1/4 ounce casting weight with a size 2 snelled hook rigged with a crawler and cast into the flat area in 5' of water. ...more Bullhead feed aggressively at night in this area. Great spot to drink some beers and hang with some buddies. Be careful in a boat here though, big rocks are less than a foot down 30' off shore.

    1. Rob Bunzey 0
      Mike bell it was supposed to be 16”
    2. mike bell 0
      60 in bullhead???
    3. View full conversation
  9. Rob Bunzey
    - Eaton Brook Reservoir

    Details: 180 in. Largemouth with a Carolina rig, dark plastics

    Post spawn, Bass will come in shallow in the morning cruising for forage, this area is very thick with vegetation in the mid to late summer months, and a turnaround ...more area for skiers and tubers, so the spring and early summer months are good to avoid both. Carolina rig a salamander in grape/junebug colors, add a couple of glass beads to your rig, and a small 1/4 tungsten weight on the less windy days. Fish the drop off near the A-frame house on the western shore. Excellent spot

    1. mike bell 0
      where is this also?
  10. Rob Bunzey
    - Eaton Brook Reservoir

    Details: 180 in. Smallies with a 10' crank bait SK 3.5

    Smallmouth Bass stack on this point after the spawn. Natural current from the in/outflow, position boat facing southwest and make long casts past the point and bring ...more across at a fairly quick speed. Chartreuse and natural shad colors work best.

Find more fishing reports in New York

  • Oneida Lake

    One of the most intensively studied and managed lakes in the nation. Widely acknowledged as the premier Walleye lake in the Northeast. Smallmouth fishing is fantastic. Good numbers of perch, Crappi...

    Followers
    1738
    Catches
    251
    Spots
    255
  • Onondaga Lake

    Onondaga Lake has become one of the premier bass fisheries in the country so much so that in 2007 it hosted a major BASS tournament that received ESPN coverage.

    Followers
    269
    Catches
    22
    Spots
    15
  • Lake Moraine

    Lake Moraine is a 2501 acre lake with a max depth of 45 feet. The muskies found here run about 30 inches, the bass run 12-15 inches, rainbows came be found commonly from 2-3lbs, and the panfish averag...

    Followers
    143
    Catches
    32
    Spots
    4
  • Leland Ponds

    If you want to catch nice trout that average 3-4lbs and nice panfish try fishing the Upper Pond. If you want to catch nice bass that average 3-4lbs as well as nice panfish and tiger muskies try fishin...

    Followers
    135
    Catches
    10
    Spots
    1
Loading...