1. Is anyone able to say if these are some type of thread fin shad or a different species?

    1. Chris Skinner 0
      100% positive on threadfin shad, the warm water at Calaveras and Braunig causes them to have brighter colors, too bad y'all didn't catch any rio grande cichlids, ...more or tilapia too
    2. SoniaD 0
      @bmftom I am totally going to do that, that's a great idea, thanks!
    3. bmftom 0
      If you have a small seine, go to the coast and drag it through the grasses along the shore. We have caught so much awesome stuff there. Pipefish, blennies, sea horses, ...more etc. @SoniaD
    4. SoniaD 0
      @bmftom We just lost our minds when we saw these come up in the cast net. They are so pretty. In our aquatic bio department the 3 grad students and our professor ...more all actually love darters oddly
    5. bmftom 0
      Well at least there are other people that are as weird as me when it comes to fish and fishing. Haha. I could read about shad all day. @SoniaD
    6. SoniaD 0
      They are aquatic biology grad students and are avid fisherman and obviously know a lot on the topic, & my professor has his doctorate in ichthyology so I was ...more torn when we didn't get a positive ID lol
    7. SoniaD 0
      @bmftom Thank you, we looked it up in our book and based on the description we also thought threadfin shad, but yesterday in the lab a bunch of guys & my professor ...more were arguing over the positive ID
    8. bmftom 0
      in their fins and the jaw, but the spot placement and yellowing is a good indication. @SoniaD
    9. bmftom 0
      They look like threadfin. I can't see really well on my phone, but the spot on the side is usually higher on a threadfin than a gizzard shad. There are other ...more small differences in the number of spines
    10. SoniaD 0
      Thanks @gr82bstr8 :)
    11. gr82bstr8 0
      Welcome to Fishing Scout!
    12. SoniaD 0
      @SwampMafia, Thank you for the welcome!
    13. Swamp Mafia 0
      Welcome to FishingScout
    14. whitebass_81 0
      Looks like atlantic bumpers to me @SoniaD
    15. SoniaD 0
      Why thank you! I'm a wildlife biology major so when I go fishing I get really into the science aspect of things as well, and I found these to be particularly ...more interesting :)
    16. christian christian 0
      Good bait right there welcome to fishing scout! :)
    17. View full conversation

Sign in or Sign Up to comment, like and view details of this activity.

or

Loading...