Some idea that I have tried on Lake Shafer and the big Monon. Brown baits work really well in this area. I have a lot of success with Brown tubs, frogs, and grubs ...more for bass and walleye. for crappie, I have had success with silver spoons or minnows that look and reflect like crappie minnow bait. I have been fishing this area for 30+years and I have tried a lot of different Jigs. Brown with a hint of yellow works great for me. Good Luck to all this fishing season.