McCotter's Lake Anna Guide Service Fishing Report/Forecast Mid September
Lake Anna, Va. - Amazing September weather has further cooled Lake 
Anna into the ...more  70s up lake and the lower eighties down lake. This has 
moved crappie to their shallower water haunts, made striper begin to 
feed consistently and pushed baitfish into the backs of creeks where 
largemouths are following. It won't be long now before the shorelines 
are ablaze with fall color.. Here's what  you can expect on your next visit.
Largemouth Bass - You can find the baitfish in 
the backs of major creeks like Sturgeon, Marshall, Serks, Pigeon, 
Contrary, Ware, Plentiful, etc. but you might not catch bass. So 
what's the deal? It's all about your timing. The lake's largemouths 
will feed early and late in the day now as they are already fat from a 
summer of plenty. What you need to do is locate the baitfish schools 
and check back three to four times a day to pattern out the feed. A 
multi-arm rig with baits the size of the bait you are seeing can be 
deadly now. If you don't want to mess with baitfish and schooled bass, 
tie on a shaky head worm and hit mid lake docks and up lake rocks. 
Down lake bass are schooled over humps and can be targeted with 
topwater walking baits, grubs and small crankbaits. 
Striped Bass - Now is the time to hunt striper. Sometimes you find 
them within five minutes of leaving the marina, sometimes it takes an 
hour. Striper are breaking just about every morning now somewhere on 
the lake. There are schools at The Splits and along the State Park and 
down between Dike 1 and Dike III. These schools mostly consist of fish 
from seven inches to 25". The bigger fish have moved up lake. You'll 
find them above the first two bridges in both the North Anna and 
Pamunkey Branches but they are trickier to pattern. Topwater walking 
baits, multi-arm rigs and Toothache spoons are the three most 
consistent producers now. Trolling and fishing with live bait is fair 
to good at times but it's difficult to remain mobile with four to 12 
lines out! Watch for seagulls in the up lake region showing you where 
to fish now.
Crappie - Once the water dropped to 80 the fish returned to docks, 
rocks and brush in 8-14' of water in the upper part of the lake. Small 
jigs, fished on 1/32-oz. jig heads are good as are minnows on slip bobbers.
Good luck and see you on the water.