Goodyear Lake

Otsego - New York


  • 13 catches

  • 67 followers

  • 15 spots

This lake contains a variety of fish species to catch with yellow perch being the most abundant. Other commonly caught fish are walleye, smallmouth bass, bluegill, and pumpkinseeds. Popular icefishing lake for panfish & walleye.

Find Local Fishing Spots on the Interactive Map!

Already have an account? Sign in

or
*Used to locate nearby fishing activity


By signing up with Fishidy you accept the User Terms and Privacy Policy.

Goodyear Lake Fishing Reports

Recently shared catches and fishing spots

  1. Stephen Fluck
    - Goodyear Lake

    Details: 18 in. Walleye with a Rapala X-Raps

    Fishing off the shore where the concrete stairs are. Used a deep diving floating crank bait. Cast out about 30 ft and pulled it up the lake bank

  2. Stephen Fluck
    - Goodyear Lake

    12 in. Largemouth Bass with a Rapala Shad Raps

  3. Stephen Fluck
    - Goodyear Lake

    Details: 16 in. Largemouth Bass with a drop rig, 12 inch lead, worm

    Caught at 830 pm. Had to walk out 10 feet from shore and cast another 20-30 to get where the fish were

  4. Stephen Fluck
    - Goodyear Lake

    Details: Smallmouth Bass with a Worm on a bobber with a 2 foot lead

    1 foot smallmouth bass, caught near the fishing pier off the park trail, maybe 10 feet out from the shore, was using a LED bobber

  5. Stephen Fluck
    - Goodyear Lake

    Details: Rock Bass with a Rapala Shad Rap Crankbait, Natural colors

    1.5 foot rockbass, evening close to sunset, long cast out into the 30' depth area

  6. Stephen Fluck
    - Goodyear Lake

    Details: Largemouth Bass with a Fake Worm-2 inches long, Brown, Drop rig, 12" Lead

    3 Largemouth bass caught within 15 min, long cast out down the bank

  7. Shawn Allen
    - Goodyear Lake

    First time fishing this lake. I am from Houston Texas here for my sons world series and there was no way I wasn't going to fish because I love it. I think this ...more is a Pike but it doesnt say that pike are known to be caught in this lake. Am I right?

    Northern Pike with a Small blue/chrome rattle trap

    1. Robert Coleman 0
      Chain Pickerel! 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
  8. nyfishingaddicts .
    - Goodyear Lake

    Details: rip rap drop off

  9. nyfishingaddicts .
    - Goodyear Lake

    Smallmouth Bass with a tip up with minnow

  10. nyfishingaddicts .
    - Goodyear Lake

    Yellow Perch with a northland buckshot

Find more fishing reports in New York

  • Otsego Lake

    Lake trout are the main sought after species. Walleye and perch are also popular. The lake supports a underfished exceptional smallmouth bass fishery. The lake is stocked annually with approximately 5...

    Followers
    183
    Catches
    7
    Spots
    5
  • Canadarago Lake

    OPRHP permit required (Central Region 315-492-1756)

    Followers
    156
    Catches
    8
    Spots
    4
  • Cannonsville Reservoir

    NYCDEP permit required (1-800-575-LAND)

    Followers
    105
    Catches
    55
    Spots
    0
  • Pepacton Reservoir

    No motors

    Followers
    95
    Catches
    25
    Spots
    1
Loading...